Its been a while since our last newsletter. Sorry!
CHANGES TO GIFTING
You may have read by now that gift duty has been repealed, but like all things the Government does it may look wonderful at first however there are a few barbs that need to be considered.
The first issue that must always be considered in relation to a sizeable gift is the issue of solvency. Solvency definition is that your assets exceed your liabilities and that you can meet your debts as they fall due. In the event that you are not solvent at the time of making a distribution or a gift, the receiver has the ability to claw back the transaction for up to two years of that transaction being made. Solvency also considers contingent liability.
Rest Home care subsidies are also a matter that needs to be considered, and for gifting a bulk asset back its deemed to be excessive gifting and can still be considered an asset in your personal name that can be used in Rest Home care subsidies. Rest Home care subsidies are very specific to individuals and for the purposes of this exercise I do not intend to go into any great depth, but if you are over 65 and you are currently looking at gifting back all of your debt to your Trust, consideration needs to be given to the excessive gifting to see if this is going to be achieved for Rest Home care subsidy.
There is also an unproven IRD issue that has yet to be considered or tested in the courts. Say for example we have a dry stock farm that’s worth $1.2 million. The husband and wife team have been farming it with beef and sheep stock over the years, and have now read about being able to put their property into Trust and gift it back as gift duty has been abolished. They decided that this is an excellent opportunity to restructure their affairs and immediately proceed in putting the $1.2 million farm into Trust. They then decide to take a lease back between the farming partnership and the Trust and continue to farm in their own names as partners of the partnership. If this was the case one could argue “is there an economic reality test here”, and by that its saying would you dispose of a $1.2 million farm and not accept any funds coming back to the individual partners. So for example in our case, it may be that the farm was sold for $1.2 million and the lease that’s going to be paid across to the trust can support a debt of $500,000. Therefore the farm is sold for $1.2 million, settled by a $500,000 mortgage and $700,000 by way of gift. The $500,000 mortgage is then paid to the individual partners, which we could suggest would be gifted back over a five year period of say a $100,000 ($50,000 each) and this could be done as any normal gifting would be done.
For the trusts that we currently act for, in terms of undertaking their gifting we are currently working through the system to determine what the best course of action is. As a general rule of thumb if your debt is less the $500,000 and there is no trading risk that we are aware of, or you are under the age of 65 (at our best guess); between now and when Maggie goes on maternity leave mid November, we will be executing all the necessary documents to gift the debt back in full.
We will however of course be contacting those clients who do fall outside of those perimeters, to discuss their individual needs to determine the best course of action.
AUSSIE HUMOUR....
Shane and Phil were a couple of drinking buddies who worked as aircraft engineers in Melbourne, Australia. One day the airport was fogged in and they were stuck in the hangar with nothing to do.
Phil said, "Man, I wish we had something to drink!". Shane says "Me too. Y'know, I've heard you can drink jet fuel and get a buzz, you wanna try it?"
So, they pour themselves a couple of glasses of high octane booze and get completely smashed. The next morning Phil wakes up and is surprised at how good he feels. In fact, he feels GREAT! NO hangover! NO bad side effects.
Then the phone rings - it's Shane. Shane says "Hey, how do you feel this morning?" Phil says "I feel great, how about you?" Shane says, "I feel great, too. You don't have a hangover?" Phil says, "No, that jet fuel is great stuff, no hangover, nothing. We ought to do this more often".
"Yeah well, there's just one thing".
"What's that?"
"Have you farted yet?"
"No, why?"
"Well DON'T - 'cos I'm in New Zealand".
IRD vs REALISTIC SALARIES
In a recent Court of Appeal decision the IRD has recently won a case against two surgeons called Mr. Penny & Mr. Hooper. The effect of the outcomes of the court have basically said we now need to have a commercial realistic salary paid were individual’s contract back to a services company. So what does this actually mean?
Well Mr. Penny & Mr. Hooper did shoot them selves in the foot because they acknowledged in open court that they would never have accepted a salary of $100,000 each if it wasn’t for the fact that they were working for an associated family company and that their trust was receiving the benefit of their labour. The question that arises is “what is a commercial acceptable salary”? In the world of professional services we could always look to say “what would we pay a locum or someone like that to step in and operate the company on an arms length basis”?
Well unfortunately case W33, a tax case involving a dentist, basically said that a locum salary wasn’t sufficient to take as an example of Market Remuneration.
So maybe you have the decision to put yourself on PAYE deducted earnings and that way you could argue a contract is in place with you contracting back to the company and taking PAYE earnings on the basis of an external Market Based Remuneration. Well that’s a great idea until you get to the problem were you get to the end of the year and you’ve got a profit sitting in your company. Now we have to apply our mind to section RD3 of the Income Tax Act which gives us a very complicated calculation of how much of a bonus can be paid out. Effectively for ever $10,000 you take in as PAYE you acquire another $5,000 worth of bonus income.
And also while considering section RD3 of the Income Tax Act you might also want to be aware that regular drawings taken weekly, fortnightly or monthly is sufficient to determine that it should be subject to PAYE. So this could affect a new business starting up who decides that they are going to pay themselves $1,000 a week. That $52,000 would be treated as income subject to PAYE.
So going forward what does Penny & Hooper mean to us? Effectively what Penny & Hooper determines is that when setting up a company and we wish to have limited liability, it is a good idea from the outsets to have the structure set up where you have family trusts involved as shareholders and contract back to the company with as close to a market assessment of your income as you can achieve.
For specific advice, if you are concerned, please contact us to discuss your particular situation.
Thank you to our clients who have been very patient with us over the death of Frank as we are now three months on from his sudden passing. We are beginning to overcome the back log of files in the Tokoroa office, but are still spread quite lightly over the two practices. This has further been compounded by Ben, who has gone back to study and is on limited hours in the company. We have identified a new person and have just formalized their contract but due to their existing work commitments they will not be starting until the 1st April 2012. This has meant that we are able to service our clients coming into the next financial year and we are doing everything possible to get on top of the back log of records, and thank you for your patients in this current financial year.
If you have not received your accounts, and they are required for an urgent purpose then please contact our office and give us a time frame so that we know were to prioritize that work. All work that is currently sitting in out office is expected to be completed before Christmas, which I would remind people which is only two months away.
THE GREAT LITTLE PUB
"Y'know" said the Scotsman, "I still prefer the pubs back home. In Glasgow there's a little bar called McTavish's. Now the landlord there goes out of his way for the locals so much that when you buy 4 drinks he will buy the 5th drink for you".
"Well", said the Englishman, "at my local, the Red Lion, the barman there will buy you your 3rd drink after you buy the first 2."
"Ahhhhh, that's nothing", said the Irishman. "Back home in Dublin there's Ryan's Bar. Now the moment you set foot in the place they'll buy you a drink, then another, all the drinks you like. Then when you've had enough drinks, they'll take you upstairs and see that you get laid. All on the house!"
The Englishman and Scotsman immediately scorn the Irishman's claims, but he swears every word is true. "Well," said the Englishman, "did this actually happen to you?"
"Not me meself personally, no", said the Irishman, "but it did happen to me sister".
MANY APOLOGIES.....
Thank you to our clients who have been very patient with us over the death of Frank as we are now three months on from his sudden passing. We are beginning to overcome the back log of files in the Tokoroa office, but are still spread quite lightly over the two practices. This has further been compounded by Ben, who has gone back to study and is on limited hours in the company. We have identified a new person and have just formalized their contract but due to their existing work commitments they will not be starting until the 1st April 2012. This has meant that we are able to service our clients coming into the next financial year and we are doing everything possible to get on top of the back log of records, and thank you for your patience in this current financial year.
All work that is currently sitting in our office is expected to be completed before Christmas, which I would remind people which is only two months away.
On that note - we would also like to remind you that Maggie and David's heir to the throne is due next month. Maggie is now only working three days a week, and will be on full maternity leave from the 14th November to the 13th February.
MAKING A BABY
The Smiths were unable to conceive children and decided to use a surrogate father to start their family. On the day the proxy father was to arrive, Mr Smith kissed his wife goodbye and said "Well, I'm off now. The man should be here soon".
Half an hour later, just by chance, a door-to-door baby photographer happened to ring the doorbell, hoping to make a sale. "Good morning ma'am", he said "I've come to...."
"Oh, no need to explain," Mrs Smith cut in, embarrassed, "I've been expecting you".
"Have you really?" said the photographer. "Well, that's good. Did you know babies are my speciality?"
"Well that's what my husband and I had hoped. Please come in and have a seat..."
After a moment she asked, blushing "Well, where do we start?"
"Leave everything to me. I usually try two in the bathtub, one on the couch, and perhaps a couple on the bed. And sometimes the living room floor is fun. You can really spread out there."
"Bathtub, living room floor? No wonder it didn't work out for Harry and me!"
"Well, ma'am, none of us can guarantee a good one every time. But if we try several different positions and I shoot from six or seven angles, I'm sure you'll be pleased with the results."
"My, thats a lot!", gasped Mrs Smith.
"Ma'am, in my line of work a man has to take his time. I'd love to be in and out in five minutes, but I'm sure you'd be disappointed with that."
"Don't I know it" said Mrs Smith quietly.
The photographer opened his briefcase and pulled out a portfolio of his baby pictures. "This was done on top of a bus" he said.
"Oh my!!" Mrs Smith exclaimed, grasping at her throat.
"And these twins turned out exceptionally well - when you consider their mother was so difficult to work with"
"She was difficult?" asked Mrs Smith
"Yes, I'm afraid so. I finally had to take her to the park to get the job done right. People were crowding around four and five deep to get a good look."
"Four and five deep?" said Mrs Smith, her eyes wide with amazement.
"Yes", the photographer replied. "and for more than three hours, too. The mother was constantly squealing and yelling - I could hardly concentrate, and when darkness approached I had to rush my shots. Finally, when the squirrels began nibbling on my equipment, I just had to pack it all in".
Mrs Smith leaned forward, "Do you mean they actually chewed on your, uh....equipment?"
"It's true ma'am, yes... Well, if you're ready, I'll set-up my tripod and we can get to work right away"
"Tripod?"
"Oh yes ma'am. I need to use a tripod to rest my Canon on. Its much too big to be held in the hand very long".
Mrs Smith fainted.